This article was originally published at 10:12 a.m. CST on Wednesday, Nov. 18. It was last updated with additional information at 3:51 p.m. CST on Wednesday, Nov. 18.
**
OMAHA (DTN) -- A bipartisan group of eight U.S. senators called on the Surface Transportation Board to reject the merger between Union Pacific Railroad and Norfolk Southern in a letter to the board Wednesday.
The proposed $71.5 billion merger would allow Union Pacific (UP) to acquire Norfolk Southern's (NS) stock, creating the largest railroad in U.S. history and extend a single rail line across 43 states from the West Coast to the East. The Wall Street Journal reports the single railroad would have 39% of rail freight market share.
The Surface Transportation Board (STB) set Nov. 18 as the deadline for written public comments for the UP-NS merger. The STB has a long list of deadlines ahead for the proposed merger, including comments from the Justice Department and Transportation Department Dec. 3. The final briefs to STB, after responses and rebuttals, are set for May 28, 2027, with expectations of a vote by the STB sometime within 90 days after.
Sen. Tammy Baldwin, D-Wis., and outgoing Sen. Roger Marshall, R-Kansas, led a letter with Sens. Martin Heinrich, D-N.M., John Hoeven, R-N.D., Steve Daines, R-Mont., Tim Sheehy, R-Mont., and outgoing Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn. The senators stated, "the merger would drastically reduce competition in freight rail, raising costs on consumers and worsening already poor service for American farmers, manufacturers, and businesses that rely on freight rail to get their goods to market."
In their letter, the senators made the case that the transaction would be the most significant consolidation of the freight rail industry in decades and would reshape U.S. freight rail and supply chains.
"Specifically, we are concerned that a merger of this magnitude could increase costs, reduce transportation options for shippers, undermine reliable service, and further diminish competition in an already highly consolidated industry," the senators wrote. "Given these significant risks to rail shippers, consumers, and the broader U.S. economy, we urge the Board to reject the proposed merger."
The senators also took issue with comments from Union Pacific CEO Jim Vena that were recently released in a video. Vena told a room of rail shippers last March that UP would raise rates on anyone who opposes the merger. Vena said he would make a deal with companies that back the merger.
"I'll probably increase everybody's rates that said they didn't want a seamless railroad by 3 or 4% to teach you a lesson," Vena said in a recording released earlier this month.
UP has said that Vena made an offhand comment and the company does not retaliate against customers.
The senators urged the STB to "take Vena's words seriously and consider whether such threats prevent shippers from raising legitimate concerns about this merger's impact on already high costs and poor service."
Other groups also weighed in Wednesday, with the National Corn Growers Association (NCGA) opposing the UP-NS merger. In nine pages of comments, NCGA noted the two railroads would finance the transaction with as much as $20 billion in debt. The railroads have not demonstrated that new traffic alone could service the debt and fund capital investments. NCGA stated that suggests the merged railroad would instead have to increase rates on existing traffic to cover the debt.
"With fewer competing rail providers, the quality of service available to agricultural shippers must be protected," said Michigan farmer Matt Frostic, president of NCGA, in comments submitted to the STB.?"Any disruptions to the freight system, whether caused by operational misalignments, infrastructure closures, or labor shortages, can cause immediate risks to U.S. farmers."
The National Grain and Feed Association (NGFA) also said reduced competition among Class I railroads would create significant risks for grain, feed and other agricultural shippers. NGFA urged the STB to deny the merger application and focus on regulatory issues to deal with longstanding challenges for railroad shippers.
"Our members depend on competitive, reliable and cost-effective rail transportation to move agricultural products to domestic and international markets. We do not believe the proposed transaction meets the public-interest standard required for approval," said Mike Seyfert, president and CEO of NGFA.
UP has filled its website with columns and statements about why companies should back the merger. In an article posted Tuesday, UP cited that Omaha-based Ag Processing Inc., a farmer cooperative, in its filing to the STB noted the merger would open additional East Coast export channels and strengthen the ability of U.S. agriculture to compete in global markets.
UP also cited that grain shippers would see fewer handoffs and faster deliveries under the merger.
"Consider a wheat shipment moving from Kansas to Pennsylvania. Today, it requires an interchange in Kansas City, where Union Pacific hands the shipment to Norfolk Southern. Under a combined network, it will move on a single railroad from origin to destination, eliminating the mid-continent handoff and reducing transit time by an estimated 36 hours," stated Jason Hess, senior vice president of Bulk, Marketing and Sales for UP.
The American Farm Bureau Federation helped launch the Stop the Rail Merger Coalition back in April to oppose the merger.
See, "Stop the Rail Merger Coalition Launches to Oppose Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern Merger" https://www.fb.org/…
Chris Clayton can be reached at Chris.Clayton@dtn.com
Follow him on social platform X @ChrisClaytonDTN
(c) Copyright 2026 DTN, LLC. All rights reserved.